Research And Publication
Home > Research And Publication
Research And Publication
Research And Publication

Trumps U.S. Tariffs and Trade Deal with China and Taiwan

2025-11-17

    The U.S. and China have been locked in a trade war ever since Trump levied tariffs on China, in his words to stop the fentanyl trade, but what happens next after Trump and Xi reduced tensions after a brief meeting in Busan, South Korea during the APEC summit? Sources say that the PRC asked Trump to make a public statement that he was against Taiwan's independence during the Trump-Xi meeting at the same APEC summit a few weeks ago.Trump has stated that he wants to travel to China in April, 2026 and sign a trade deal but will this be part of a grand bargain giving up Taiwan in exchange for economic concessions? Taiwan and the rest of the world are concerned that because Trump is a transactional president and only concerned about monetary concessions that a grand bargain could very well be in the works. What will Xi Jinping be willing to give up in order to sign a trade deal and would he want to reward Trump with a victory for starting this trade war? Simultaneously, the Supreme Court could strike down Trump's tariffs and give China a big win.

    Xi Jinping holds the cards right now in this trade war. China's choke hold of rare earth minerals has helped Xi put extreme leverage in dealing with Trump and the U.S. U.S. representative John Moolenaar said "that at the end of the day Xi has the final say in what happens in a trade deal and what he determines makes China the winner." Trump's new trade deal will look to lock down these rare earth minerals until the U.S. and the rest of the world can catch up. Instead of a grand bargain I see Xi doing just enough to sign a deal. He will continue buying soybeans most recently agreeing to 25 million metric tons annually through 2028. China will buy semiconductors but Trump will not sell Nvidia's Blackwell, next generation AI chip. The U.S. will be pushing airplane parts and specifically try and get China to purchase Boeing airplanes. China has been moving away from Boeing and towards Airbus and it will be hard to reverse this trend. China will also buy more oil and natural gas from Alaska. GM, Ford, and Tesla all have had increased Chinese tariffs but not as much as the 250% tariffs on Chinese EV's that the U.S. charges. Xi would be smart to try and get these tariffs down to the 15% that South Korea and Japan pay or at least lower the tariffs to make them realistically affordable to the U.S. consumer. Opening the U.S. market to Chinese EV's would also reduce protectionist tariffs in other markets like Canada and the European Union. If the U.S. won't play fair and reduce the tariffs then China should reciprocate with the exact amount of tariffs on GM's, Fords, and Tesla's sold in China.

    Trump wants to bring back America's manufacturing but the U.S. is severely lacking in skilled manufacturing labor, but what worries trade representatives most is the coming second shockwave of Chinese manufacturing particularly in solar panels, electric vehicles, and other green technologies.

    Craig Singleton, a former U.S. diplomat, said that "Trump is both transactional and muscular and Trump is not an isolationist but an aggressive internationalist competing in most domains and using economic leverage against endless dialogue that goes nowhere." U.S. House Representative Adam Smith stated that "Trump started the trade war and weakened our position by not understanding where the leverage existed and how to use it. Trump's approach to tariffs is more about personal power than any grand strategy. Is that part of a strategic plan for the U.S. or is it about stroking Trump's ego? Tariffs are undermining America's broader economic strategy in China and the rest of the world," Smith said.

     Will the Trump administration come up with a grand bargain with Xi that undermines Taiwan's independence in order to get economic gains for the U.S.? Secretary of State Marco Rubio said, “If what people are worried about is we’re going to get some trade deal where we’re going to get favorable treatment on trade in exchange for walking away from Taiwan — no one is contemplating that." Ryo Sahashi from the University of Tokyo said "Japan has no clue where Trump stands on Taiwan and is more worried about carrots than sticks like the U.S. giving up Taiwan for semiconductors." Dan Bloomenthal former senior director for China at the US department of defense said, "the Trump administrations main strategy for Taiwan is multi domain access denial." He thinks there will be no grand bargain for Taiwan but the "Trump administration will strengthen Taiwan's deterrence, get allies to up spending, and ask allies to make a statement supporting Taiwan." He also said "Trump won't provide strategic clarity. Clarity comes from actions. Helping Taiwan with deterrence."

     A grand bargain for China would involve the U.S. recognizing China's rise and giving unrestricted access to U.S. markets and technologies while allowing annexation and reunification with Taiwan. The U.S. wants China to limit aggression in the East and South China Seas and leaving Taiwan alone. The U.S. also wants China to fix its non-market policies and to embrace democracy. Neil Thomas, a fellow on Chinese politics at the Asia Society said "Beijing is not chasing a grand bargain but seeking a truce to buy time and build leverage." He added that while Washington and Beijing both prioritize self-reliance over interdependence, Xi is betting that his strategic resolve will outlast Trump’s.Trump is easily manipulated by strong men like Xi and Putin so would Trump kill the goose that lays the golden egg, destroying something valuable or profitable out of greed or impatience by giving up Taiwan?

      The U.S. is looking to finish a trade deal with Taiwan before the end of the month. The deal will be similar to what South Korea and Japan completed with a 350 billion investment pledge from South Korea and a 550 billion dollar investment from Japan. A trade official said that Taiwan should expect to pay something in the middle of the 350 and 550 billion that South Korea and Japan will pay and they are currently going back and forth on the final amount.The U.S. is still considering  tariffs on semiconductors, which would have a large impact on Taiwan while Taiwan refused to split semiconductor 50/50 with the U.S. as a hedge of protection for the island. Taiwan will also buy more U.S. goods, like agricultural products, military equipment, and energy.

     What could upend these trade deals and tariff negotiations is the Supreme Court ruling in several months. If the Supreme Court rules against Trump and says the tariffs are illegal by then the U.S. will have to refund close to a trillion dollars. What happens to all of these tariff negotiations? Unfortunately for the U.S. if countries increase tariffs or leave them at retaliatory rates in an act of bad faith, then the U.S. could possibly be unable to counter them. Congress would have to get involved and it just keeps spiraling into a big mess. Trump could have some limited tariffs lasting for 150 days, for example, but the Trump administrations options would be limited. It looks like the Supreme Court is leaning towards saying the tariffs are illegal so it is up to countries to negotiate a trade deal knowing that these tariffs may go away.

      Xi Jinping has the upper hand in these trade talks realizing the U.S. needs critical rare earth minerals and can't function without them. Trump has stated that he won't play hard ball with China in this trade deal but will Xi? Probably not but he should. Xi will appease his U.S. counterparts by doing just enough to end these tariffs. There is no need to reward the U.S. for this trade war and handing Trump a big win in any kind of grand bargain seems highly unlikely. The tariffs will reset and Trump will claim a big victory and the world's two largest economies can get back to leading instead of tit for tat retaliations in a trade war that benefits no one.

     The Trump administrations options for a trade deal have narrowed considerably after Xi punched the U.S. in the mouth with rare earth restrictions. The U.S. has some leverage with Microchips and airplane parts but this is Xi's trade deal to lose. He can force the U.S. into accepting a bare bones trade deal that reduces tariffs and does very little to address any long term concerns of the U.S. but does just enough to get the U.S. to accept it. The U.S. will likely accept the terms reached at the APEC summit and look to advance further negotiations with Boeing and U.S. agricultural products and natural gas and oil but Xi should try and get the tariffs reduced on Chinese EV's. The hawkish forces in the Trump administration will push the U.S. away from a grand bargain giving up Taiwan for economic concessions and like Xi it is ultimately up to Trump to decide what the U.S. will accept in a trade deal not the hawks in his administration. China will want to eliminate port fees in a trade deal and after doing so for the next year the U.S. will likely grant this request.

   When Adam Smith stated that "Trump started the trade war and weakened our position by not understanding where the leverage existed and how to use it," he was referring to the leverage the U.S. has with our allies, economic and  military strength. Many experts believe that the U.S. is losing this trade war and showed the U.S. vulnerabilities like rare earths and agricultural products that no one else was buying when China left the market. There are 196 countries and the U.S. isn't the only market. Pretty soon allies and China will move on from an unstable trading partner like the U.S. China's trade with the U.S. is down considerably this year and look for this to continue as China recalibrates from this trade war even with a signed trade deal. China renigged on some of the agreements in Trumps last trade deal with them so nothing will keep them from doing it again. Representative Smith also said that the China- U.S. rivalry is not a zero sum game with only one winner. There is room to compete together and the world will profit off our AI, space, and technological advances over the course of this century and it shouldn't be that the U.S. has to win at all costs. He said he is trying to get other congressmen to see the big picture telling them them there is room for both countries to compete successfully. Smith believes there are other ways of coercing China then blanket tariffs on them and our allies.

     China will sign a trade deal without giving up too much while Trump and the U.S. will look for a huge win that won't be there. Taiwan will most likely have to pay several hundred billion dollars at the end of this month unless they work out an unlikely agreement with TSMC. Taiwan will keep decoupling from China as a trading partner and it would be wise to do so. You can't possibly win a potential war, especially if you are an island, if your largest trading partner is the enemy. The U.S. would have never defeated Nazi Germany and Imperialist Japan if they were are our number one trading partners.

  Finally this trade war has shown that China is the U.S.'s peer and not subordinate. Xi could prove that China has indeed arrived by playing hard ball with the U.S. and gaining concessions that would show the world to look at China's authoritative model instead of a broken democracy. Now would be the time to do it.


© 2026 Center for Asia-Pacific Security and Taiwan Studies  All Rights Reserved.