Research And Publication
Home > Research And Publication
Research And Publication
Research And Publication

Geopolitical Triangles: EU, US, China & India in a Multipolar World

2025-10-07

1. Introduction

1.1 Background: Global Power Shifts & Trade Dynamics

Over the past decade, global power dynamics have transformed significantly. The rise of India, the growing assertiveness of China, and evolving U.S. trade and foreign policy have contributed to a more contested international order. Protectionist trends in the U.S., technological competition with China, and geopolitical tensions in the Indo-Pacific have reshaped trade relations and exposed vulnerabilities in global supply chains, particularly during crises such as the COVID-19 pandemic and the war in Ukraine. These disruptions have forced many states, including those in Europe, to reconsider their geopolitical and trade dependencies (1,2).

Europe, and the European Union in particular, now finds itself at a strategic inflection point. On one hand, the U.S. expects greater alignment from its allies in matters of trade, regulation, and security. On the other hand, China remains a major partner in trade and supply of critical inputs, but concerns over transparency, regulatory practices, and strategic intent have grown. India, meanwhile, is emerging as both a trading opportunity and a strategic counterbalance, given its economic growth and democratic credentials. Thus, the EU must navigate a complex environment where trade, diplomacy, and values intersect and sometimes clash (3,4).

1.2 Key Concepts: Balancing, Hedging, Strategic Autonomy

To frame the EU’s approach in this setting, three interrelated concepts are essential:

· Balancing refers to efforts by a state or bloc to align its policies and partnerships in response to power rivalries, so as not to become overly dependent on a single power.

· Hedging is a strategy of keeping one’s options open—engaging with multiple powers without committing fully to any one bloc, thereby preparing for different potential future alignments (2,5).

· Strategic Autonomy, a concept increasingly central in EU discourse, is the ambition to act independently in economic, diplomatic, security, and technological domains—making policy choices less constrained by external pressures and dependencies (3,6).

These concepts overlap: balancing and hedging are often tactical or strategic responses, whereas strategic autonomy is more of a goal or framework within which these responses are situated (1,3).

1.3 Purpose & Structure of Report

The purpose of this report is to analyse how the EU is managing the dual pressures of U.S. expectations and its trade relations with China and India. Specifically, it will examine how the practices of balancing and hedging are reflected in EU policy, and how these contribute to or complicate the pursuit of strategic autonomy. The report will map the EU’s strategic context; then review responses, tensions, and case studies; finally assessing trade-offs, constraints, and offering policy recommendations. Figures and tables will illustrate trade volumes, dependencies, and recent trends to ground the analysis.

2. The EU’s Strategic Context

2.1 U.S. Pressure: Trade, Diplomacy, Security Demands

The United States over recent years has intensified pressure on the EU in multiple domains: trade (tariff threats, regulation of standards), diplomacy (expectations of alignment in foreign policy), and security (defence cooperation, shared technology governance). The EU is confronted with U.S. measures such as steel and aluminium tariffs, demands regarding digital regulation and semiconductor supply chains, and expectations that EU policy supports U.S. geopolitical priorities (2,7). These pressures test the EU’s ability to pursue its own interests, especially when U.S. policy swings under different administrations.

2.2 Trade Ties with China and India: Volumes, Dependencies, Opportunities

China continues to be a key import partner for the EU: a large share of the EU’s imports in manufacturing goods and critical inputs come from China. Similarly, EU exports to China have grown, though regulatory hurdles and non-tariff barriers remain significant (5,7). India’s trade with the EU, although smaller in volume compared to China, has been growing both sides have renewed interest in concluding or reviving a free trade agreement, and expanding cooperation in technology, services, and investment (8,3). India offers opportunities for diversification of supply chains, market expansion, and a partner in shared geopolitical challenges (8).

2.3 Emerging Multipolarity & Supply Chain Disruptions

The global order is becoming more multipolar, with India rising alongside other regional actors. Concurrently, crises such as the pandemic, the war in Ukraine, and climate-related shocks have exposed fragilities in just-in-time supply chains and overconcentration of crucial inputs. These disruptions have prompted the EU to develop strategies for resilience, de-risking (for example “China+1” sourcing), and investment in critical capacity within or allied to Europe (7,1). All of this forms the backdrop against which the EU must chart its course: neither fully aligned with U.S. directives nor passively dependent on China, but seeking a path that preserves flexibility, trade prosperity, and geopolitical relevance.

Table 1: Trends in EU Trade Balance with US, China, India

Partner

Notable Data / Year

EU Trade Balance (Goods) / Status

Additional Facts or Share of EU Trade

United States

2024

EU had a goods trade surplus with US of ~ +€198 billion in 2024.

In 2024, US was EU’s largest export destination (20.6% of extra-EU exports)

China

2024

EU had a goods trade deficit with China; the deficit was reported to widen to about −€306 billion in 2024.

In 2024, China was EU’s largest import partner (21.3%)

India

2023-2024

Trade balance in goods is in favour of India (i.e. EU imports > EU exports to India), e.g. in 2023, favouring India by ~ €16.545 billion.

In 2024, trade in goods between EU & India ≈ €120 billion, and India accounted for ~2.4% of EU’s total goods trade.

 

3. Strategic Autonomy and EU Policy Responses

3.1 Evolution of EU’s Strategic Autonomy: Definitions & Priorities

The concept of strategic autonomy for the European Union has broadened over recent years. Whereas earlier debates focused mainly on defence and security, current EU strategic autonomy also includes economic independence, technology, supply chain resilience, and regulatory sovereignty. The 2022 European Parliament Research Service briefing defines strategic autonomy as the capacity to act without being overly dependent on other states in key policy areas. Priorities have shifted toward semiconductors, critical materials, energy independence, and clean-technology to support both green and digital transitions.

3.2 Key Policy Instruments and Initiatives

To implement strategic autonomy, the EU has deployed several policy tools:

· European Chips Act: For example, the EU recently approved €920 million in German state aid for Infineon’s “MEGAFAB-DD” plant in Dresden, intended to strengthen the EU’s semiconductor manufacturing capacity, supply chain resilience, and technological autonomy. This project is slated to reach full capacity by 2031 (10)

· Hydrogen & Clean Energy Procurement Rules: In September 2024, the EU changed its hydrogen project auction rules to limit Chinese-made parts to no more than 25% of a plant’s production capacity, part of a drive to reduce dependencies in renewable energy supply chains (9).

3.3 Open vs Restrictive Approaches: Trade-off Analysis

The EU tends to favour an “open strategic autonomy” approach preserving trade and cooperation while gradually introducing restrictions where dependencies pose strategic risks. The hydrogen auction rules limiting Chinese component sourcing are a case in point (9). However, such restrictions can increase costs, delay deployment, complicate regulatory compliance, and provoke diplomatic friction. For instance, while the Infineon plant investment boosts domestic production and resilience, it depends on state aid and large public subsidies and timing, regulatory approvals, and industrial coordination remain challenging. (10)

4. Areas of Tension & Risk

4.1 Trade Imbalances and Dependencies (US, China, India)

Heavy dependencies in critical technologies pose strategic risk for the EU. The hydrogen sector’s reliance on Chinese parts for electrolysers, for instance, has raised concerns about the EU’s supply chain vulnerability. In response, the auction rule change (25% cap on Chinese-made parts) aims to reduce that dependency (9). The semiconductor domain similarly shows that despite the Chips Act’s ambitions, production capacity in Europe is currently lower and catch-up will require major investment and regulatory support. The Infineon MEGAFAB-DD project is an example of stepping up EU’s internal capacity and reducing dependency (10).

4.2 Diplomatic Expectations vs Domestic Pressures

Externally, the EU faces pressure from the U.S. to align on trade, technology, defence, and regulatory standards; China and India also exert influence via trade relations and investment. Domestically, cost, competitiveness, and industrial capacity vary across Member States. For example, the decision to limit Chinese components in hydrogen auction rules was pushed by domestic hydrogen equipment manufacturers complaining of unfair competition from cheaper Chinese imports (9). The Infineon plant is supported by state aid, but not all Member States have the ability or will to fund similar semiconductor infrastructure projects (10).

4.3 Internal Coherence among EU Member States

Fragmentation among Member States is a recurring risk. Some are more willing to invest heavily in industrial strategy and accept regulatory constraints, while others are more cautious. The hydrogen auction rule change, for example, must be implemented across different national jurisdictions and projects must comply with new criteria this requires coherence in implementation (9). The MEGAFAB-DD plant reflects a Member State (Germany) taking initiative and obtaining EU backing, but similar efforts in other states may face financial, regulatory, or political obstacles (10).

Figure 2 illustrates the EU’s sectoral dependencies on China, India, and the U.S. for critical supply chains. The data reveal that China dominates EU imports in areas such as rare earths and clean technology inputs, with dependency levels often exceeding 60%, reflecting a high-risk concentration. This over-reliance poses strategic risks if geopolitical tensions or export restrictions disrupt supply.

Pharmaceutical APIs present a different profile: dependencies are shared between India and China, creating a medium level of vulnerability. India plays a particularly important role in supplying affordable active pharmaceutical ingredients, making it difficult for the EU to substitute suppliers quickly.

By contrast, dependencies on the U.S. are generally lower in upstream materials but more significant in specialized chemicals and advanced manufacturing inputs. In automotive EV components, China again plays a strong role through batteries and rare earth magnets, underscoring the exposure of Europe’s green transition to Chinese supply chains.

Overall, the figure highlights how sectoral vulnerabilities are uneven: rare earths and EV components are marked as high-risk, pharmaceuticals as medium, and some ICT components as moderate to high. These insights underscore the importance of the EU’s policy push for open strategic autonomy, particularly through initiatives such as the European Chips Act and the Critical Raw Materials Act, aimed at reducing dependency and strengthening resilience.

5.EU Strategy to curb US Pressure

5.1 EU–China: De-Risking and Economic Security Measures

The EU’s relationship with China is characterized by a mix of economic interdependence and strategic rivalry. China is the EU’s largest import partner, supplying critical goods such as electronics, clean technology components, and rare earths. However, this dependency has raised concerns about strategic vulnerabilities. In 2023, the European Commission explicitly adopted a “de-risking, not decoupling” approach toward China, aiming to reduce critical dependencies without severing trade ties (11).

Concrete measures include the European Critical Raw Materials Act, which sets targets to ensure no more than 65% of EU demand for any critical material is met by a single non-EU country (12). Similarly, the EU’s industrial policy seeks to diversify supply chains through partnerships with resource-rich countries in Africa and Latin America. In technology, the European Chips Act mobilises €43 billion to expand domestic semiconductor capacity, directly responding to reliance on Chinese and Asian supply chains (13).

Case examples highlight both successes and limits. The hydrogen auction redesign in 2024, which capped Chinese components at 25%, illustrates EU willingness to impose targeted restrictions to safeguard strategic sectors (9). At the same time, trade data show that over 70% of EU solar PV panels and large portions of battery imports still come from China, underscoring persistent vulnerabilities (11). The balance reflects the EU’s strategy: safeguarding autonomy in high-risk areas while maintaining overall trade openness.

5.2 EU–India: Trade Agreement Negotiations & Diverging Priorities

The EU views India as a key partner for diversification away from China. Bilateral trade in goods reached approximately €120 billion in 2024, making the EU India’s second-largest trading partner (14). Negotiations for an EU–India Free Trade Agreement (FTA), relaunched in 2022 after years of stagnation, aim to deepen cooperation in goods, services, investment, and sustainable development (15).

However, progress has been slow due to diverging priorities. The EU has pressed for stronger commitments on labour rights, environmental standards, and digital governance, while India has emphasized market access for its textiles, pharmaceuticals, and IT services. Agricultural tariffs and intellectual property protections remain contentious issues (15).

Despite these challenges, interim frameworks such as the EU–India Trade and Technology Council (TTC) established in 2022 have provided platforms for cooperation in digital policy, green technologies, and resilient supply chains (14). Importantly, India’s large pharmaceutical and API sector is seen as a vital diversification source for Europe, particularly given the bloc’s reliance on China in this domain (12).

The EU’s outreach to India thus reflects both economic and geopolitical calculations: engaging a rising democratic power in Asia while hedging against over-dependence on China. Yet unless compromises are reached on standards and tariffs, the ambitious EU–India FTA may remain elusive, highlighting the structural divergences between the two partners.

6. Trade-offs, Constraints & Policy Recommendations

6.1 Economic Costs vs Strategic Benefits of Autonomy

While strategic autonomy offers the EU greater resilience in geopolitically sensitive sectors, it comes with non-trivial economic costs. For example, a policy brief by ECIPE estimates that EU strategic autonomy initiatives could reduce trade openness and impose long-term income losses of around 0.08% to 0.15% of EU27 GDP, due to shifts in resource allocation and less efficient supply chains. Frontier Economics similarly estimates potential losses between USD 12-22 billion annually, with even higher costs in productivity if restrictions are tightened.  However, the strategic benefits can outweigh these costs in the medium term: reduced vulnerability to external supply shocks, enhanced geopolitical leverage, better control over critical inputs (raw materials, energy, tech), and stronger alignment between values and trade/security policy. The war in Ukraine, disruptions in energy and supply chains during COVID-19, and U.S. export controls all illustrate how over-dependence on external suppliers can rapidly become a liability. Thus, the EU faces a trade-off: pursuing autonomy may mean higher costs, lost efficiency, perhaps slower growth in certain sectors in the short term; but failing to do so could expose the EU to higher costs over time, in both economic and security terms (16,17).

6.2 Managing Diplomatic Relations: Balancing U.S. Expectations and Asia Engagement

Diplomatically, the EU must walk a fine line. The U.S. expects European partners to align on trade rules, technology governance, export controls, and security cooperation. At the same time, Asia especially China and India is too big a market and too important a partner to alienate completely. Engaging Asia offers diversification of trade, alternative investment, and strategic partnerships (e.g. in supply chains, technology, green energy) (18).

However, aligning too closely with U.S. positions risks backlash from Asian partners or being seen as sacrificing autonomy. Conversely, moving too far toward Asia or decoupling from U.S. expectations may invite punitive measures (tariffs, regulatory pressure) or weaken transatlantic cooperation. The recent strategic autonomy discourse emphasises “open strategic autonomy” to try to reconcile these pressures being open and cooperative where possible, but asserting autonomy in critical areas (`19).

Therefore, EU policy must calibrate diplomatic posture: cooperating with the U.S. on shared concerns (security, climate, technology standards) while resisting policy overreach; engaging China/India in trade and dialogue, but with clear guardrails; and ensuring messaging and reciprocity so that EU interests are not undermined by external pressure (19,20).

6.3 Recommendations: Partner Diversification, Regulatory/Industrial Policy, Monitoring Dependencies

Based on the above trade-offs and constraints, here are policy recommendations:

1. Partner Diversification

Strengthen trade and investment relations with Asia beyond China: India, Southeast Asia, ASEAN, and bilateral/regional trade agreements.

Develop “friend-shoring” strategies: preferential trade or supply chain links with reliable (ally or partner) countries.

2. Regulatory & Industrial Policy Measures

Use industrial policy (subsidies, public investment) in critical sectors (semiconductors, green tech, rare earths) to build capacity within the EU.

Apply regulatory standards and trade defence measures to manage risk: e.g., stricter due diligence, standards for clean tech sourcing, export control reciprocity.

Industrial coordination among Member States to avoid fragmentation and duplication.

3. Monitoring Dependencies and Assessing Risk

Develop robust mapping of supply chains and dependencies (raw materials, components, upstream processing) across sectors; identify chokepoints.

Regular risk assessments, scenario planning (e.g., for export restrictions, geopolitical shock); build buffer capacity where feasible.

Transparent metrics: define what level of dependency is acceptable, which sectors are critical, thresholds for intervention.

4. Economic & Budgetary Supports

Use EU budget tools (NextGenerationEU, RRF, etc.) to finance strategic projects.

Encourage Member States to coordinate fiscal policy so as to absorb costs without destabilising national budgets.

5. Diplomatic Strategy

Maintain multilateral frameworks, international cooperation, and dialogue even with strategic competitors.

Use the EU’s trade and investment diplomacy to shape norms (digital regulation, sustainability, human rights) so that external partners have aligned incentives.

7. Conclusion

7.1 Key Findings: How the EU Is Balancing Pressure & Trade Relations

The analysis shows that the EU is pursuing open strategic autonomy, trying to maintain trade openness while addressing vulnerabilities in supply chains and geopolitical pressures. It has taken concrete steps—policy instruments, regulatory reforms, industrial investment—to reduce dependency in sectors flagged as high-risk, while carefully managing relations with both the U.S. and Asia. The EU is not opting for full decoupling but rather selective restriction and regulation in strategically critical domains.

7.2 Implications for EU’s Global Role

If successful, this balancing act could strengthen the EU’s role as a credible global actor that can mediate between superpower rivalries, contribute to a rules-based trade order, and act with economic weight and ethical coherence. It could also increase the EU’s leverage in negotiations (trade, security, climate) by reducing vulnerabilities. On the other hand, failure or miscalibration (overrestrictiveness, weak enforcement, internal disunity) could erode competitiveness, strain diplomatic relations, or lead to strategic overextension.

7.3 Future Outlook: Challenges and What to Watch

Looking ahead, there are several challenges to monitor:

· Member State divergence: Differences in capacity, priorities, political will remain a risk.

· Fiscal constraints and economic shocks: Inflation, investment costs, energy crises may limit how much EU and its members can afford autonomy policies.

· Technological disruption: Rapid change (AI, quantum, biotech) could shift what is “critical” unexpectedly. EU must be agile.

· Geopolitical volatility: Policies in the U.S., China, India (export controls, trade wars, strategic competition) may force sudden shifts.

· Global rule-based trade environment: If multilateral institutions weaken, or norms erode, EU may need to navigate more ad hoc or fragmented regimes.

In sum, the EU’s journey toward strategic autonomy is complex and fraught with trade-offs. But by carefully calibrating its policies, investing in resilience, and staying diplomatically nimble, the EU has an opportunity to maintain both its economic prosperity and its strategic sovereignty in a multipolar world

© 2026 Center for Asia-Pacific Security and Taiwan Studies  All Rights Reserved.