Research And Publication
Home > Research And Publication
Research And Publication
Research And Publication

Japanese Prime Minister Takaichi’s “If Taiwan Is in Trouble, Japan Is in Trouble” Remark Calls for Attention to Cross-Strait Peace — China Deliberately Distorts the Statement

2025-12-19

I. Takaichi Truthfully Responded to Parliamentary Questioning: If Taiwan Is in Trouble, Japan Will Indeed Be Affected

On November 7, Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi stated in response to questioning by a member of the House of Representatives that if a contingency were to occur in Taiwan accompanied by the use of force, it could potentially constitute a “survival-threatening situation” under Japan’s security legislation, in which the exercise of the right of collective self-defense might be permitted—though any such determination would depend on specific circumstances.

On November 8, Xue Jian, China’s Consul General in Osaka, reposted Japanese media coverage of Takaichi’s remarks on the social media platform X, adding the comment: “That filthy head that dares to intrude should be chopped off without hesitation.” This statement was a malicious slander against Japan’s head of government and was extremely egregious.

Under Japanese law, government officials are required to respond truthfully when answering questions in the Diet. Takaichi’s response was therefore both lawful and factually grounded. During China’s military exercises around Taiwan on August 4, 2022, artillery shells landed in waters near Yonaguni Island and Hateruma Island, causing serious anxiety among local fishermen and posing grave threats to the safety of Japanese citizens. When Taiwan faces a crisis, Japan is indeed affected. China has never apologized for these actions; instead, it insulted Japan’s prime minister.

The Japanese government subsequently lodged a protest with China, warning that if Beijing failed to take corrective action, Japan might consider stronger measures, including designating Xue Jian as persona non grata and demanding that he return to China. Frankly speaking, there are few diplomats in the world with such a low level of conduct as Xue Jian.

China’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs protested against questioning by Japanese legislators—an internal matter of Japan—and demanded that Prime Minister Takaichi retract her remarks simply because China did not like what it heard. Beijing then incited anti-Japan sentiment, urging Chinese citizens not to travel to or study in Japan, delaying the resumption of Japanese seafood imports already agreed upon, and even spreading false claims in the media that Japan suffers from poor public security.

Under the sway of extreme anti-Japan sentiment, China has lost its rationality. The Chinese Foreign Ministry’s deliberate distortion and criticism of Japan are utterly unworthy of a so-called major power and should be held accountable by the international community.

II. Peace in the Taiwan Strait Concerns East Asian Stability and Is a Shared Concern of Indo-Pacific Countries

Peace and stability in the Taiwan Strait are of critical importance to Japan’s security. Japan’s southwestern islands lie in close proximity to Taiwan, and in recent years China has repeatedly conducted military exercises around Taiwan, with shells at times at risk of falling into Japanese waters, threatening fishermen and residents of nearby islands.

Prime Minister Takaichi’s response to parliamentary questioning was a factual description of situations that have already occurred and could plausibly recur in the future. It was an entirely accurate and honest reply.

China’s understanding of peace in the Taiwan Strait diverges sharply from that of the international community. Ignoring widespread concern, China insists on treating Taiwan as part of its territory and conducts military exercises in the surrounding waters, effectively regarding the Strait as an internal sea. This behavior perpetuates tensions and endangers neighboring countries.

China’s claim that both sides of the Strait belong to “one China” originates from internal Kuomintang documents and has no legal force, yet it has caused confusion internationally. Japan, however, shares deep historical ties with Taiwan and understands this history well; China’s attempts at obfuscation cannot deceive Japan.

The global environment—particularly in the Indo-Pacific—has changed. Former Prime Minister Shinzo Abe recognized this shift and urged the Japanese public to reassess the international landscape. As China grows stronger and seeks to unilaterally alter the status quo in the Taiwan Strait, it paradoxically demands that Japan abide by outdated post-World War II arrangements.

Prime Minister Takaichi is a prudent leader. She has carried forward Abe’s recognition of changing global realities by urging Japan to strengthen its self-defense capabilities while aligning with Europe and the United States in calling for peace and stability in the Taiwan Strait. This has been reflected in Japan’s gradual increase in defense spending and revisions to outdated elements of its national security legislation.

These measures are a necessary response to China’s frequent incursions into the waters around the Senkaku Islands and even into Japanese airspace. Stability in the Taiwan Strait is a matter of international concern and is vital to East Asian security. China’s irrational protests deliberately undermine the fragile peace in Sino-Japanese relations.

III. Japan Has Consistently Honored Sino-Japanese Agreements; China Is the One Undermining Stability

Since its defeat in World War II, Japan has strictly adhered to its pacifist constitution. Its military is still called the Self-Defense Forces, numbering only about 260,000 personnel, and is focused solely on territorial defense. Any overseas deployment for peacekeeping missions requires special legislation approved by the Diet, including restrictions on the carrying and use of weapons. Even if a Taiwan contingency were to occur, Japan could not dispatch forces without parliamentary authorization.

China’s protests deliberately ignore Japan’s legal framework and falsely portray Japan as reviving militarism—claims entirely fabricated. Only under pressure from U.S. President Donald Trump to increase defense spending did Japan, after heated parliamentary debate, raise its defense budget to 1.4% of GDP—still below NATO’s former 2% benchmark and far from the 5% demanded by the United States.

China’s claim that Japan’s defense strengthening represents militarism is a deliberate attempt to sabotage bilateral stability. In reality, Japan follows alliance-guided diplomacy under the U.S.-Japan security framework, bearing significant costs for hosting U.S. forces while facing long-standing restrictions on military development. Only recently has the U.S. urged all host nations—including Japan, South Korea, and Germany—to increase defense expenditures.

China’s portrayal of this externally driven adjustment as Japan’s independent militarization is fundamentally false.

IV. China’s International Campaign Gains No Support and Only Embarrasses Itself

China’s criticism of Japan has failed to gain international traction. At the UN Security Council, China’s ambassador Fu Cong loudly proclaimed that Japan is unqualified to become a permanent member. On the 21st, he wrote to UN Secretary-General António Guterres accusing Prime Minister Takaichi of “serious violations of international law.”

The alleged violation was merely Takaichi’s hypothetical response in parliament that if China were to attack Taiwan, Japan’s existing security mechanisms might allow Self-Defense Forces deployment. Her remarks simply reaffirmed Japan’s commitment to peace in the Taiwan Strait. Fu Cong’s reaction exposed China’s anxiety over the possibility of Japan and the United States jointly deterring the use of force.

Japan’s contributions to international peace are widely recognized. China, by contrast, has failed to oppose Russia’s invasion of Ukraine at the United Nations yet dares to question Japan’s qualifications. The absence of international support for China’s criticism shows that its aggressive rhetoric is widely disregarded.

Such behavior only reveals China’s indifference to peace and its willingness to destabilize the region, further demonstrating Japan’s suitability—rather than China’s—for greater international responsibility.

V. Peace in the Taiwan Strait Is a Core East Asian Concern and an International Consensus

Peace in the Taiwan Strait underpins economic prosperity across East Asia. Japanese and South Korean energy imports and trade routes, as well as U.S. shipping interests, pass through surrounding waters. Maintaining stability is therefore an international consensus.

Recent Chinese naval exercises suggest a possible blockade strategy aimed at isolating Taiwan. U.S.-Taiwan security cooperation is designed to prepare for such contingencies. China’s intent to undermine peace is well understood internationally. Any attempt to legitimize an invasion through the UN Security Council would be vetoed by democratic states; unilateral aggression would be deterred by the U.S.-Japan alliance and severely damage China’s own economy.

Without peace, there can be no stable economic development—a truth known to the Chinese people themselves.

Although Sino-Japanese relations have deteriorated following Takaichi’s remarks, Japanese public support for her leadership has risen. According to recent Yomiuri Shimbun polling, her approval stands at 72%, while Asahi Shimbun reports 56% support. This demonstrates that the Japanese public stands firmly behind her government.

China should recognize that peace in the Taiwan Strait is an international consensus. Attacking Takaichi will only further unite the Japanese people under her leadership and strengthen cooperation with the United States in deterring aggression, reinforcing global support for maintaining the status quo.


© 2026 Center for Asia-Pacific Security and Taiwan Studies  All Rights Reserved.