Research And Publication
Home > Research And Publication
Research And Publication
Research And Publication

Trump’s Political Mindset and the Triangular Dynamics of U.S.–Taiwan–China Relations

2025-07-16

Donald Trump's return to the presidency has intensified uncertainty in global politics and has direct implications for the triangular relationship among the United States, Taiwan, and China. This article argues that Trump's foreign policy orientation reflects a Jacksonian populist tradition that prioritizes national interests over liberal values, bilateral deals over multilateral cooperation, and executive aggrandizement over institutional checks and balances. By contrasting Trump's “America First” approach with the Wilsonian liberal internationalism exemplified by President Joe Biden, the paper highlights a paradigmatic shift in U.S. foreign policy. The study further explores how China may exploit America's retreat from multilateralism to expand its global influence, while outlining policy adjustments Taiwan must pursue to safeguard its interests. Ultimately, Taiwan's resilience depends on adopting a pragmatic, interest-driven diplomatic strategy and cultivating a more comprehensive understanding of American conservatism and Jacksonian populism.

 

Introduction

The inauguration of Donald Trump for a second term has had a profound impact on global politics. For Taiwan, this change reverberates directly through the triangular dynamics involving the United States and China. Trump's foreign policy instincts—rooted in populism, commercial realism, and skepticism toward traditional alliances—demand that Taiwan reassess its diplomatic strategies. This paper analyzes the theoretical underpinnings of Trump's worldview, its practical implications for U.S.–China competition, and the adaptive responses Taiwan must consider.

 

Trump's Jacksonian Legacy and Executive Aggrandizement

Trump's admiration for President Andrew Jackson illuminates his approach to foreign policy and presidential power. Both figures are characterized by combative personalities and an expansive conception of executive authority. Jackson's era of radical democratization and anti-elitism mirrors the populist fervor surrounding Trump's rise. Like Jackson's supporters, Trump's political base is deeply skeptical of elites, experts, and institutions.

 

This political culture marks a departure from Wilsonian liberal internationalism, which justified U.S. global engagement in moral and institutional terms. Instead, Trump's “America First” reflects a Jacksonian populism in which U.S. involvement abroad is legitimate only when narrowly tied to tangible national benefits.

 

Interests Above Values: Trump's Commercial Realism

In sharp contrast to Biden's reliance on the Democratic Peace framework—which emphasizes democracy, economic interdependence, and institutions as pacifying forces—Trump elevates material interests over values. His mercantilist orientation frames diplomacy as transactional, distinguishing between “ingroup” partners who share interests and “outgroup” rivals whose divergent priorities generate mistrust and conflict.

 

This perspective explains Trump's responses to conflicts such as the Russia–Ukraine war and the Israel–Hamas crisis, where value-based arguments were supplanted by interest-based calculations. For Trump, peace and cooperation are contingent not on shared ideology but on converging material interests.

 

China's Prospects in Multilateral Governance

Trump's skepticism toward multilateralism and preference for bilateralism may reduce U.S. visibility in international organizations, creating openings for China to expand its influence.

 

Strengthening leadership in existing frameworks: China is likely to consolidate its role in the Belt and Road Initiative, the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, and BRICS. Its official development assistance, offered with minimal conditionalities, positions Beijing as an attractive alternative to Western donors for developing countries.

 

Anticipating Trump's transactional diplomacy: Trump is not unwilling to trade resources for strategic gains, as demonstrated by his recognition of Moroccan sovereignty over Western Sahara in 2020 in exchange for Morocco's normalization with Israel. This precedent suggests that under Trump, the United States may provide resources abroad, but only when such actions directly serve U.S. interests.

 

Policy Implications for Taiwan

Trump's transactional orientation presents both risks and opportunities for Taiwan. To navigate this environment, Taiwan must recalibrate its diplomacy:

 

Strategic awareness: Enhance understanding of American conservatism and Jacksonian populism.

 

Interest-based engagement: Prioritize bargaining strategies that emphasize shared material interests.

 

Institutional capacity: Elevate negotiators with expertise in transactional diplomacy.

 

Adaptive flexibility: Implement rapid, rolling policy adjustments in response to global developments.

 

Taiwan's foreign policy cannot rely exclusively on democratic values as its diplomatic currency. Instead, a pragmatic mix of interests and values will be essential to preserving Taiwan's agency in the triangular relationship.

 

Conclusion

Trump's second presidency reinforces a Jacksonian populist paradigm that prioritizes national interests over liberal values, bilateralism over multilateralism, and executive dominance over institutional constraints. This shift will inevitably reshape the U.S.–Taiwan–China relationship. For Taiwan, resilience requires pragmatic adaptation: strengthening transactional capacities, anticipating China's expanding global role, and cultivating a more comprehensive understanding of U.S. political traditions. Only through such adjustments can Taiwan preserve its strategic leverage amid the uncertainties of a Trump-led international order.

 


© 2026 Center for Asia-Pacific Security and Taiwan Studies  All Rights Reserved.